1. Introduction
Plague remains one of the best-studied yet conceptually challenging natural focal infectious diseases because of the ability of its etiological agent, Y. pestis, to persist in natural ecosystems for prolonged periods. Despite substantial advances in understanding plague biology and transmission, the mechanisms that allow Y. pestis populations to persist during prolonged inter-epizootic periods remain incompletely understood [1,2,3,4].
Long-term observations from natural plague foci in Central Asia, Kazakhstan, the Caspian region, Mongolia, China, Africa, and North America have demonstrated pronounced temporal variation in epizootic activity, with active periods alternating with prolonged intervals of apparent inactivity. In some plague foci, Y. pestis was not isolated for decades before epizootic activity reappeared [1,2,3]. Related evidence concerning plague persistence has been reported in Kazakhstan and Central Asia, as well as in experimental studies of environmental survival [4,5,6].
The classical epizootiological concept describes plague maintenance primarily through the rodent–flea–rodent transmission cycle [1,2]. Although this model explains the principal mechanism of epizootic transmission, it does not fully account for prolonged inter-epizootic intervals or the re-emergence of plague activity after extended periods without bacteriological detection. Experimental and field studies have therefore examined additional mechanisms that may contribute to pathogen persistence, including survival in soil and burrow substrates [7,8,9,10,11,12], intracellular persistence in free-living amoebae [13,14,15], biofilm formation and other adaptive physiological states [16,17,18,19,20], and associations with plant rhizospheres and other environmental substrates [21,22].
These observations have led to broader ecological concepts in which plague persistence may involve interactions among reservoir hosts, flea vectors, environmental substrates, soil biota, and adaptive states of Y. pestis. However, the strength of evidence differs among these proposed mechanisms: some are supported by the recovery of viable bacteria or experimental observations, whereas others are based on molecular detection or ecological associations. Consequently, environmental detection of Y. pestis DNA should not by itself be interpreted as evidence of viable bacterial persistence or of a confirmed environmental reservoir.
Kazakhstan, with its extensive and long-monitored natural plague foci, provides an opportunity to examine these mechanisms across multiple spatial and temporal scales. Accordingly, the present study integrates published evidence with long-term epizootiological surveillance, field and laboratory investigations, and spatial data from the natural plague foci of Kazakhstan. The aim was to characterize long-term host–vector and spatial patterns, evaluate field and laboratory evidence from selected natural foci, and integrate these findings with published data into an ecological framework of Y. pestis persistence, while distinguishing demonstrated observations from hypothesized persistence mechanisms.
2. Materials and Methods
The study integrated historical and long-term epizootiological surveillance data, original field and laboratory investigations, spatial analyses, and published evidence to examine ecological mechanisms associated with the persistence of Y. pestis in the natural plague foci of Kazakhstan. The design, temporal coverage, geographic scope, and analytical role of each evidence component are described below.
2.1. Study Design and Data Sources
This study used a descriptive and integrative design combining several complementary evidence streams that differed in temporal coverage, geographic scale, and analytical purpose. These included historical epizootiological records from Kazakhstan (1926–2022); long-term epizootiological surveillance data (1990–2025); original field and laboratory investigations conducted during 2021–2023; recent host–vector monitoring data from the national anti-plague surveillance system (2021–2025); and published national and international studies addressing ecological mechanisms of Y. pestis persistence.
The datasets were analyzed according to their respective temporal and methodological scope and were not treated as a single pooled dataset. Historical and surveillance records were used to characterize long-term spatial and epizootiological patterns, whereas the 2021–2023 project provided original environmental, bacteriological, serological, and molecular data from selected natural plague foci. Published studies were used for comparative evaluation of proposed persistence mechanisms.
Integration of these evidence streams was performed at the interpretative stage to develop the ecological framework of Y. pestis persistence in the natural plague foci of Kazakhstan. The scope and analytical role of each evidence stream are summarized in Table 1.
2.2. Literature Survey and Comparative Ecological Analysis
The literature survey included classical studies of plague ecology [1,2], investigations conducted in Kazakhstan and other endemic regions [4,5,6,11,12,22,23], and experimental studies addressing environmental persistence and ecological adaptation of Y. pestis [7,10,13,14,15,16,18,20]. Published evidence was comparatively evaluated according to the environmental or biological substrate investigated, conditions associated with pathogen survival, reported duration and type of persistence evidence, proposed mechanisms, and potential ecological significance. Particular attention was given to distinguishing recovery of viable Y. pestis from molecular detection of bacterial DNA and from proposed or experimentally inferred persistence mechanisms.
2.3. Integrated Ecological Framework
Evidence from the literature, long-term epizootiological surveillance, field and laboratory investigations, and spatial analyses was integrated at the interpretative stage to develop an ecological framework of Y. pestis persistence. The framework considered interactions among reservoir hosts, flea vectors, environmental substrates, soil biota, and adaptive bacterial states. Evidence was interpreted according to its level of support, distinguishing demonstrated observations from potential or hypothesized persistence mechanisms.
2.4. Long-Term Epizootiological Monitoring (1990–2025)
Long-term epizootiological monitoring data from the natural plague foci of Kazakhstan were used to characterize spatial and temporal variation in the principal components of the host–vector system and plague activity. Monitoring covered the major natural plague territories of the country and included annual field surveys of rodent populations and their ectoparasites, with particular attention to the great gerbil (R. opimus), the principal reservoir host in desert plague foci. Field surveillance and epizootiological assessment were conducted according to established methodological approaches for epidemiological surveillance in natural plague foci [24].
The monitored parameters included the area occupied by great gerbil colonies, burrow occupancy, host population density, flea abundance, evidence of epizootic activity, and the extent of annually surveyed territories. Monitoring records were analyzed descriptively to characterize long-term ecological and spatial patterns rather than to test formal temporal trends.
2.5. Field Investigations and Sample Collection (2021–2023)
Original targeted field investigations were conducted during 2021–2023 in selected natural plague foci of Kazakhstan. The investigations included five autonomous plague foci containing recurrent enzootic core areas (Ural–Emba, North Aral, Aral–Karakum, Balkhash, and Ili Intermountain) and three comparison foci (Kyzylkum, Moyynkum, and Betpakdala). Detailed field surveys covered approximately 120,000 km2, with individual expedition routes ranging from approximately 300 to 1000 km.
This targeted survey area was distinct from the substantially larger territory covered annually by the national anti-plague surveillance system (approximately 738,000–744,000 km2 during 2021–2025).
The study design included targeted investigation of territories associated with recurrent plague activity and comparative examination of selected territories in which no active plague epizootics had been recorded in recent years.
A total of 4586 environmental and biological samples were collected, comprising 1388 rodent-burrow soil samples, 725 burrow-substrate samples, 399 feeding-chamber content samples, 1168 sets of rodent biological samples, including liver, spleen, blood, and serum, 868 ectoparasite suspensions, and 38 rodent skeletal remains. Soil samples were collected from great gerbil (R. opimus) burrows at depths of 50, 100, 150, and 200 cm. Soil pH, temperature, moisture content, and salinity were assessed to characterize the physicochemical conditions of the burrow microenvironment.
Field sampling was conducted together with epizootiological observations of host and flea-vector populations.
2.6. Laboratory Investigation of Field Samples
Field materials collected during the 2021–2023 investigations were examined using bacteriological, serological, and molecular methods routinely applied within the national plague surveillance system of Kazakhstan and described in the relevant methodological guidelines [25,26,27,28].
Bacteriological examination of appropriate biological and environmental materials was performed for the isolation and identification of viable Y. pestis according to established methodological guidelines [25,26]. Recovered cultures were identified using standard bacteriological and phenotypic criteria, followed by characterization of their principal biological properties and biovar determination. For bacteriological examination of rodents, liver, spleen, and blood samples were used.
Rodent serum samples were used for F1-specific immunological testing and real-time PCR.
Serological investigations were performed according to established plague diagnostic procedures [26] using passive hemagglutination-based assays. F1-specific immunological testing included detection of the F1 capsular antigen and anti-F1 antibodies in rodent serum samples, whereas ectoparasite suspensions were examined for F1 antigen.
Molecular examination was performed by real-time PCR for the detection of Y. pestis DNA according to validated methodological recommendations [27,28]. DNA extraction was performed using the RealBest UniMag kit (Vector-Best JSC, Koltsovo, Novosibirsk Region, Russia) and the RIBO-prep kit (Central Research Institute of Epidemiology, Moscow, Russia). Molecular identification of Y. pestis isolates was performed using the Plague qPCR test system developed by the M.
Aikimbayev National Scientific Center for Especially Dangerous Infections (Almaty, Kazakhstan) and the AmpliSens diagnostic system (Central Research Institute of Epidemiology, Moscow, Russia). Real-time PCR was applied to all 4586 field samples collected during the targeted investigations, comprising 1388 rodent-burrow soil samples, 725 burrow-substrate samples, 399 feeding-chamber content samples, 1168 rodent serum samples, 868 ectoparasite suspensions, and 38 rodent skeletal remains. PCR-positive results were interpreted specifically as molecular detection of Y. pestis DNA and not as evidence of bacterial viability.
Bacteriological, serological, and molecular findings were recorded separately according to diagnostic method, sample type, and study territory. All procedures involving viable Y. pestis were conducted within the institutional biosafety and containment framework established for work with particularly dangerous pathogens at the M. Aikimbayev National Scientific Center for Especially Dangerous Infections, in accordance with the applicable national biosafety requirements.
2.7. GIS and Spatial Analysis
Spatial analysis was performed to characterize the geographic organization and long-term distribution of plague activity within the natural plague foci of Kazakhstan. Historical epizootiological records, long-term national surveillance data, field observations, laboratory findings, and data on the spatial distribution of the principal reservoir host and flea vectors were integrated for comparative spatial analysis.
Enzootic cores were defined as geographically persistent areas characterized by recurrent plague activity over long-term observation periods. Their identification was based on the spatial recurrence of epizootiological evidence, including detection and isolation of Y. pestis, together with the long-term presence and spatial stability of the principal host–vector system. Historical and contemporary epizootiological records were compared spatially to identify territories in which plague activity repeatedly occurred within the same geographic areas.
Spatial mapping and analysis were performed using ArcGIS 10.8 (Esri, Redlands, CA, USA). GIS-based mapping was used to visualize the spatial distribution of plague activity and to delineate the boundaries of the identified enzootic cores. The spatial analysis identified four major clusters of recurrent enzootic core areas, which were further compared with the distribution of reservoir hosts and flea vectors and with relevant landscape and environmental characteristics.
The resulting spatial data were analyzed descriptively and integrated with field, laboratory, and ecological evidence to evaluate the role of geographically stable enzootic cores within the proposed ecological framework of Y. pestis persistence.
2.8. Comparative and Statistical Analysis
The study was primarily descriptive and comparative in design. Quantitative data were summarized using absolute numbers, proportions, percentages, ranges, and annual or territory-specific indicators, as appropriate. Comparisons were performed among natural plague foci, sample types, observation periods, and selected ecological characteristics.
Long-term surveillance data on great gerbil distribution, burrow occupancy, population density, flea abundance, and epizootiological activity were evaluated descriptively to characterize temporal and spatial variation. Annual values were compared across observation periods without formal statistical trend modeling. Accordingly, temporal changes were interpreted as descriptive patterns rather than statistically tested trends.
Laboratory findings were summarized separately by diagnostic method, sample type, and study territory. For each diagnostic method, positivity rates were calculated using the number of samples examined by that method as the corresponding denominator and were expressed as percentages. Bacteriological isolation, serological detection of F1-specific immunological markers, and real-time PCR detection of Y. pestis DNA were analyzed and interpreted as distinct diagnostic outcomes.
No formal inferential statistical analyses or hypothesis-testing procedures were performed. Consequently, observed differences among territories, periods, sample types, or ecological characteristics were interpreted descriptively and were not considered statistically significant associations. The epizootiological, environmental, laboratory, and spatial findings were subsequently integrated with published evidence at the interpretative stage to develop the proposed ecological framework of Y. pestis persistence.
3. Results
3.1. Comparative Analysis of Ecological Niches and Potential Persistence Mechanisms of Y. pestis
Published evidence indicates that the long-term persistence of Y. pestis may involve multiple environmental niches and bacterial adaptive states that differ substantially in the strength and type of supporting evidence (Table 2). Reported persistence ranges from short-term experimental survival to prolonged field observations, and evidence based on recovery of viable bacteria should be distinguished from molecular detection of bacterial DNA and from hypothesized ecological mechanisms.
Comparative analysis suggested that longer reported persistence tended to occur in settings providing greater environmental protection, including stable microclimatic conditions, organic substrates, intracellular localization, biofilm development, and metabolically inactive physiological states (Figure 1).
Among abiotic environments, soil and rodent burrow substrates have been most frequently associated with prolonged survival of Y. pestis, with viable bacteria reported under favorable environmental conditions [5,7,11,12]. Experimentally demonstrated persistence has also been reported for L-forms in nesting material for at least 427 days [17]. By contrast, evidence concerning persistence in flea carcasses and feces remains limited, and the duration of viable bacterial persistence in such organic material is uncertain (Table 2).
Several biotic environments have been investigated as potential persistence niches. Experimental studies demonstrated intracellular survival of viable Y. pestis in Acanthamoeba castellanii for at least 5–7 days [13,14,15], whereas other soil protozoa, nematodes, soil microbiota, and plant-associated habitats remain less well characterized and are supported mainly by experimental observations, ecological associations, or proposed mechanisms [2,21,22,23]. Biofilm formation and adaptive physiological states, including L-forms and persister cells, may further increase tolerance to environmental stress [16,17,18,19,20].
Thus, the available evidence supports consideration of several abiotic and biotic niches and adaptive bacterial states as potential contributors to inter-epizootic persistence. However, their evidentiary support varies considerably, and not all proposed environmental niches have been demonstrated to maintain viable Y. pestis under natural conditions.
3.2. Population Dynamics of the Great Gerbil–Flea Host–Vector System in the Natural Plague Foci of Kazakhstan
Long-term epizootiological monitoring during 2021–2025 characterized the population status of the great gerbil (R. opimus) and associated flea populations across the principal desert plague foci of Kazakhstan (Table 3). The annually surveyed area ranged from 737,890 to 743,890 km2. Mean great gerbil burrow occupancy increased descriptively from 52.9% in 2021 to 59.8% in 2025, with annual ranges of 17.61–88.55% across monitored territories.
Mean great gerbil density varied from 483 to 540 individuals/km2, and the annual abundance category fluctuated between low and moderate.
The mean flea index on great gerbils remained relatively stable at 3.9–4.3 fleas/host. Mean flea abundance in burrows ranged from 29.4 to 53.5 fleas/burrow, while mean abundance on monitoring plots ranged from 135.5 to 173.0 fleas/plot. Estimated flea abundance increased descriptively from 15,856 individuals/km2 in 2021 to 27,867 individuals/km2 in 2025, although the annual flea abundance category remained classified as low throughout the observation period.
Field observations additionally showed that flea infestation of captured rodents ranged from 0.2% to 25.7%, whereas flea occurrence in examined burrows ranged from 0.5% to 42.5%. Other rodent species were recorded at comparatively low abundance, ranging from 2.1% to 10.3% per 100 trap-nights.
Overall, the 2021–2025 surveillance data document the continued presence of great gerbil populations and associated flea populations across the monitored desert plague territories. These host–vector observations provide the ecological context for evaluating their potential contribution to the maintenance and recurrent activity of Y. pestis in the natural plague foci of Kazakhstan.
3.3. Spatial Distribution of Persistent Enzootic Cores in the Natural Plague Foci of Kazakhstan
Long-term epizootiological records from 2000–2025 combined with GIS-based spatial analysis identified geographically localized areas of recurrent plague activity within the natural plague foci of Kazakhstan. These areas, hereafter referred to as enzootic cores, were characterized by repeated detection of plague activity over the observation period and were concentrated predominantly within desert and semi-desert landscapes (Figure 2).
Four major spatial clusters of enzootic cores were identified:–Western cluster (Ural–Emba and Ustyurt regions), 18,131 km2;–Aral–Kyzylkum cluster, 27,042 km2;–Balkhash cluster, 56,239 km2;–Ili Intermountain cluster, 78,236 km2.
These clusters contained areas with recurrent Y. pestis detection and/or serological evidence of plague activity during long-term surveillance. Their locations also overlapped with territories in which human plague cases and outbreaks were historically recorded [33]. Fine-scale spatial analysis showed that recurrent plague activity was heterogeneously distributed within the larger natural foci.
Enzootic cores occurred predominantly in areas associated with alluvial and deluvial–proluvial deposits and shallow freshwater groundwater, whereas epizootic activity was less consistently recorded in aeolian sand and more arid landscapes [33].
Descriptive temporal analysis further showed that 79.0% of infected sectors and 73.7% of Y. pestis isolates included in the corresponding long-term dataset were recorded during descending phases of solar cycles, with the reported frequency being 2.7-fold higher than during ascending phases [33]. These observations are presented as descriptive temporal patterns and were not subjected to inferential testing in the present study.
Overall, the spatial analysis identified persistent enzootic cores as geographically restricted areas of recurrent plague activity within the much larger natural plague territories of Kazakhstan. Their long-term spatial recurrence provides a framework for examining the ecological conditions associated with repeated detection and re-emergence of plague activity, but does not by itself demonstrate continuous persistence of viable Y. pestis within these locations.
3.4. Field and Laboratory Characterization of Enzootic Core Areas
Field investigations conducted during 2021–2023 covered approximately 120,000 km2 of natural plague foci in Kazakhstan. Five autonomous foci containing recurrent enzootic core areas (Ural–Emba, North Aral, Aral–Karakum, Balkhash, and Ili Intermountain) were examined together with three comparison foci (Kyzylkum, Moyynkum, and Betpakdala). A total of 4586 field samples were collected, comprising 1388 samples of rodent-burrow soil, 725 burrow-substrate samples, 399 samples of feeding-chamber contents, 1168 sets of rodent biological samples, including liver, spleen, blood, and serum, 868 ectoparasite suspensions, and 38 skeletal remains.
Laboratory examination combined bacteriological, serological, and molecular methods according to sample type (Table 4). Detailed diagnostic results according to sample type and method are presented in Supplementary Table S1.
Bacteriological examination was performed on 4548 samples and yielded 24 Y. pestis isolates (0.53%). Culture-positive samples were detected in the Ural–Emba (3/572; 0.52%), North Aral (1/573; 0.17%), Aral–Karakum (10/575; 1.74%), Balkhash (7/688; 1.02%), and Ili Intermountain (3/523; 0.57%) foci, whereas no culture-positive samples were detected in the Kyzylkum, Moyynkum, or Betpakdala comparison foci. All 24 recovered isolates belonged to the Medievalis biovar.
Nineteen exhibited the typical phenotypic characteristics of this biovar, whereas five isolates showed atypical phenotypic features, including reduced F1 production and/or a decreased proportion of pigmented colonies.
F1-specific immunological testing was performed on 2074 samples comprising rodent sera, ectoparasite suspensions, and skeletal remains. Among the 1168 rodent serum samples, eight were positive for F1 capsular antigen, and the same eight samples were also positive for anti-F1 antibodies. F1 antigen was additionally detected in 66 ectoparasite suspensions.
Overall, 74 samples (3.57%) were positive by F1-specific immunological testing. Positive findings occurred in the Ural–Emba (3/265; 1.13%), North Aral (11/265; 4.15%), Aral–Karakum (4/265; 1.51%), Balkhash (12/378; 3.17%), and Ili Intermountain (44/213; 20.66%) foci, while no positive serological results were obtained in the three comparison foci.
Real-time PCR was applied to all 4586 field samples and detected Y. pestis-specific DNA in 88 samples (1.92%) (Table 4). PCR-positive findings occurred exclusively in the five foci containing recurrent enzootic core areas, whereas no positive samples were detected in the three comparison foci. By sample category, PCR-positive results were obtained from burrow soil (4/1388; 0.29%), burrow substrates (6/725; 0.83%), feeding-chamber contents (4/399; 1.00%), rodent sera (8/1168; 0.68%), and ectoparasite suspensions (66/868; 7.60%); none of the 38 skeletal-remain samples was PCR-positive.
The highest proportion of PCR-positive findings was observed among ectoparasite suspensions.
Taken together, culture recovery, serological findings, and molecular detection showed that laboratory evidence of Y. pestis circulation during 2021–2023 was concentrated in the five investigated foci containing recurrent enzootic core areas, whereas none of the three comparison foci yielded positive results by the applied methods. Importantly, the different diagnostic endpoints represent distinct levels of evidence: bacteriological isolation confirms recovery of viable Y. pestis, whereas serological findings and PCR detection indicate specific immunological markers and bacterial DNA, respectively, and do not independently demonstrate bacterial viability.
3.5. Long-Term Dynamics of the Great Gerbil Range and Environmental Patterns Associated with Plague Activity
Long-term surveillance data indicated substantial changes in the spatial distribution of the great gerbil (R. opimus) in the Betpakdala Desert during 1990–2025. Over this period, the area occupied by R. opimus, corresponding to the spatial extent of the Betpakdala autonomous plague focus, increased by 50.12% and reached approximately 60,140 km2. The northern distribution limit extended beyond 47° N, with new gerbil colonies recorded in areas outside the previously documented range.
These observations indicate a marked northward and spatial expansion of the principal reservoir host within this natural plague focus [33].
Long-term surveillance also showed pronounced seasonal variation in plague activity. Epizootic manifestations were recorded predominantly between April and November, coinciding with the period of greatest activity of rodent hosts and flea vectors. Temporal comparison with solar-cycle phases showed that 79.0% of plague-positive sectors and 73.7% of Y. pestis isolates were recorded during descending phases of the analyzed solar cycles; the reported frequency of plague activity during descending phases was 2.7-fold higher than during ascending phases [33].
Together, these long-term observations demonstrate temporal and spatial variation in host distribution and plague epizootic activity in Kazakhstan. The expansion of the R. opimus range in Betpakdala and the concentration of plague detections during particular seasonal and longer-term periods provide descriptive evidence of the dynamic spatial and temporal organization of natural plague foci. Because these analyses were descriptive, the observed associations should not be interpreted as demonstrating a causal effect of climatic or solar-cycle variability on Y. pestis circulation.
3.6. An Integrated Ecological Model of Long-Term Y. pestis Persistence in Natural Plague Foci
Integration of the field observations, long-term surveillance data, and published evidence considered in this study provides a basis for a conceptual model of Y. pestis persistence in natural plague foci (Figure 3). Rather than attributing long-term maintenance to a single mechanism, the model considers interactions among the classical rodent–flea transmission cycle, spatially structured host populations, environmental substrates, and adaptive bacterial states. The strength of evidence, however, differs among these components, and several proposed environmental mechanisms remain hypothetical rather than demonstrated reservoirs of viable Y. pestis.
The rodent–flea system represents the best-established biological component of plague maintenance. In Kazakhstan, the spatial organization of great gerbil (R. opimus) populations may further contribute to long-term enzootic continuity through connectivity among colonies. Local interruption of transmission within individual colonies does not necessarily imply disappearance of the pathogen from the wider focus, where circulation may continue in other host–vector populations.
Environmental substrates may provide additional persistence niches. In the present study, Y. pestis was recovered by culture from several field-material categories, while real-time PCR additionally detected Y. pestis-specific DNA in burrow soil, burrow substrates, feeding-chamber contents, rodent sera, and ectoparasite suspensions. These findings demonstrate the presence of viable bacteria in culture-positive material and bacterial DNA in PCR-positive samples, respectively, but PCR detection alone does not establish prolonged environmental viability or an independent environmental reservoir.
Experimental and observational studies cited in this review have proposed several additional mechanisms that could contribute to environmental survival, including biofilm formation [16,19,20], interactions with free-living amoebae [13,14,15,23], L-forms and persister states [17,18], associations with plant rhizospheres [21,22], and transition to a viable-but-non-culturable (VBNC) state [9]. These mechanisms may enhance survival under particular environmental conditions, but their contribution to long-term persistence in Kazakhstan’s natural plague foci has not been directly quantified in the present study.
Molecular-genetic evidence provides a complementary perspective. Molecular typing and genomic studies have demonstrated substantial phylogenetic and geographic structuring within Y. pestis populations, including Central Asian lineages [34,35,36,37]. Such genetic structuring is compatible with long-term maintenance within established natural foci, although it does not identify the ecological compartment or mechanism responsible for survival during inter-epizootic intervals.
Taken together, these observations support an integrated framework in which long-term plague maintenance may emerge from interactions among established host–vector transmission, spatial connectivity of reservoir populations, environmental exposure pathways, and bacterial survival strategies. The model therefore distinguishes well-established components of plague ecology from potential persistence mechanisms requiring further experimental validation. This distinction is particularly important for surveillance: conventional monitoring of rodents and flea vectors remains central, whereas environmental and molecular investigations can provide complementary evidence and help identify mechanisms that warrant targeted investigation.
3.7. Study Limitations and Future Research Directions
Several limitations should be considered when interpreting the findings of this study. First, the study integrates heterogeneous evidence derived from long-term surveillance, targeted field investigations, laboratory analyses, and previously published experimental and molecular studies. These data streams differed in temporal coverage, spatial resolution, sampling design, and analytical approach and were therefore integrated conceptually rather than subjected to pooled statistical analysis.
Second, the field and laboratory data provide different levels of evidence for Y. pestis occurrence and persistence. Culture-positive samples demonstrate recovery of viable bacteria, whereas real-time PCR confirms the presence of Y. pestis-specific DNA but does not establish bacterial viability or the duration of environmental persistence. Similarly, detection of Y. pestis in environmental material does not by itself demonstrate that soil or other environmental substrates function as independent long-term reservoirs.
Several mechanisms incorporated into the proposed model—including interactions with free-living amoebae, biofilm-associated survival, L-forms, persister cells, rhizosphere associations, and the viable-but-non-culturable state—are supported primarily by previously published experimental or geographically restricted studies and were not directly demonstrated in the present field investigation.
Third, the long-term ecological and spatial analyses were primarily descriptive. Differences in surveillance intensity, sampling effort, and temporal coverage may influence comparisons among periods and territories, and the observed associations with climatic, seasonal, and solar-cycle variables should not be interpreted as evidence of causality. Likewise, the delineation of persistent enzootic cores identifies areas of recurrent plague activity but does not demonstrate continuous presence of viable Y. pestis throughout the entire inter-epizootic period.
Future studies should therefore combine longitudinal standardized sampling with culture-based detection, quantitative molecular methods, genomic and metagenomic approaches, and high-resolution spatial and environmental data. Particular attention should be given to experimentally testing the viability and duration of Y. pestis persistence in environmental substrates and to distinguishing transient contamination from biologically relevant persistence niches. Integration of these approaches with genomic surveillance and host–vector monitoring could provide a more rigorous basis for evaluating the relative contribution of different persistence mechanisms and for refining ecological models of natural plague foci.
4. Discussion
The present study integrates long-term surveillance, spatial analyses, field and laboratory investigations, and published evidence to examine ecological processes associated with the long-term maintenance of plague in Kazakhstan. The recurrent concentration of plague activity within geographically defined enzootic cores, together with host–vector dynamics and laboratory evidence of Y. pestis circulation, supports a multifactorial interpretation of plague persistence rather than attribution to a single ecological mechanism.
The classical rodent–flea transmission cycle remains the best-established mechanism of plague maintenance and transmission during active epizootics [31,38]. Fleas may also contribute to persistence during periods of reduced transmission activity [29]. In Kazakhstan, however, plague activity is spatially heterogeneous within natural foci [33].
Metapopulation dynamics of great gerbil (R. opimus) colonies may contribute to landscape-scale continuity despite local extinction or temporary interruption of infection [30]. Comparable long-term spatial structuring of plague activity has been described in other endemic systems [39,40].
Environmental conditions may further influence the spatial and temporal organization of plague activity. Associations with precipitation, climatic variability, and other environmental factors have been reported in geographically distinct plague-endemic settings [41,42,43]. Soil salinity and aridity have also been associated with the distribution of plague foci, while the environmental tolerance of Y. pestis has been investigated as a possible contributor to persistence under particular conditions [44,45].
Nevertheless, environmental detection should not be equated with an independent reservoir: in the present study, culture-positive material demonstrated viable Y. pestis, whereas PCR-positive samples demonstrated bacterial DNA without establishing viability or duration of environmental persistence.
Molecular evidence provides a complementary perspective on long-term continuity. Molecular typing and genomic approaches have demonstrated substantial phylogenetic and geographical structuring within Y. pestis populations [34,35]. Studies of Central Asian lineages further demonstrate regional diversification and spatial structuring of plague populations [36,37].
Such genetic continuity is compatible with long-term maintenance within established natural foci but does not identify the ecological compartment in which viable bacteria persist during inter-epizootic periods.
The broader geographical literature similarly demonstrates that plague systems can remain active or re-emerge after prolonged intervals. Long-term persistence in Madagascar reflects interactions among hosts, flea vectors, and local environmental conditions [46,47]. Plague reappeared in Algeria after approximately five decades and in Libya after a prolonged period without reported cases [48,49].
Persistent plague-endemic landscapes have also been described in Brazil and elsewhere in Latin America [50,51]. These observations demonstrate recurrent plague activity across diverse ecological settings but do not imply a common mechanism of persistence among geographically distinct foci.
Additional bacterial survival mechanisms may contribute under particular environmental conditions. Persister states represent a recognized form of phenotypic bacterial persistence [32], while free-living amoebae can provide intracellular niches for pathogenic microorganisms [52]. Biofilm formation and other adaptive traits have also been proposed as mechanisms facilitating Y. pestis circulation and maintenance in natural-focus ecosystems [53].
In the framework proposed here, these processes should therefore be considered potential complementary mechanisms rather than established components operating simultaneously within Kazakhstan’s plague foci.
Overall, the findings support an evidence-weighted ecological framework in which established rodent–flea transmission operates within spatially structured host populations and heterogeneous environments, while additional environmental and bacterial survival mechanisms remain plausible but incompletely validated. Longitudinal studies combining standardized field sampling, culture-based detection, genomic surveillance, and environmental data will be required to determine their relative contributions to long-term plague maintenance.
5. Conclusions
This study integrates long-term epizootiological surveillance, spatial analyses, field and laboratory investigations, and published evidence to provide an ecological framework for understanding the long-term maintenance of Y. pestis in the natural plague foci of Kazakhstan. The findings indicate that plague persistence is spatially heterogeneous and is associated with recurrent enzootic core areas, the host–vector system, and the spatial organization of the great gerbil (R. opimus) populations.
Culture-confirmed recovery of viable Y. pestis, together with serological and molecular evidence of pathogen circulation, supports the continued activity of established natural plague foci. However, detection of Y. pestis DNA in environmental material does not by itself demonstrate bacterial viability or confirm an independent environmental reservoir. Accordingly, environmental substrates and proposed adaptive mechanisms, including biofilms, interactions with free-living amoebae, persister and VBNC states, and rhizosphere associations, should be regarded as potential complementary persistence mechanisms requiring further field and experimental validation.
Overall, the proposed model emphasizes interactions among established host–vector transmission, spatially structured reservoir populations, environmental conditions, and potential bacterial survival strategies. This evidence-weighted framework may support more targeted ecological surveillance and future studies aimed at identifying the mechanisms underlying long-term plague persistence.