Paradoxical pain localization and mirror-image laparoscopic cholecystectomy in situs inversus totalis: a case report and literature review.

Save

Background:

Situs inversus totalis (SIT) is a rare congenital anomaly characterized by complete mirror-image transposition of the thoracic and abdominal organs. Although laparoscopic cholecystectomy is the standard treatment for symptomatic gallstone disease, reversed anatomy creates unique diagnostic and technical challenges for both surgeons and radiologists. An even less common phenomenon is paradoxical right upper quadrant (RUQ) pain despite a left-sided gallbladder, which may delay diagnosis by masking biliary disease behind an apparently normal pain pattern.

Case presentation:

A 48-year-old Persian woman presented with a 2-day history of progressively worsening RUQ pain. Physical examination demonstrated localized tenderness without generalized peritonitis. Routine electrocardiography unexpectedly revealed dextrocardia, prompting further radiologic investigation.

Abdominal ultrasonography demonstrated multiple gallstones within a left-sided gallbladder, while contrast-enhanced computed tomography confirmed complete SIT. After comprehensive preoperative cardiologic and anesthetic assessment, laparoscopic cholecystectomy was successfully performed using a mirror-image operating room configuration and reversed trocar placement. Despite altered anatomical orientation and ergonomic challenges, the critical view of safety was achieved before clipping and division of the cystic duct and artery.

Histopathological examination confirmed chronic calculous cholecystitis. Recovery was uneventful, and the patient remained symptom-free at 6-month follow-up.

Conclusion:

This case highlights that the principal challenge in SIT extends beyond mirror-image anatomy to include paradoxical symptom localization and altered operative ergonomics. Recognition of laterality disorders, comprehensive preoperative imaging, and meticulous ergonomic adaptation allow laparoscopic cholecystectomy to be performed safely while maintaining the same fundamental surgical principles applied to patients with normal anatomy.

Introduction

Laparoscopic cholecystectomy is among the most commonly performed abdominal procedures worldwide and has become the standard treatment for symptomatic gallstone disease. Its safety relies on predictable anatomical relationships, accurate interpretation of clinical findings, and well-established ergonomic principles during dissection of Calot’s triangle. In patients with situs inversus totalis (SIT), however, these assumptions are fundamentally altered because the thoracic and abdominal organs are completely transposed into a mirror-image configuration.HIGHLIGHTSSitus inversus totalis (SIT) may present with paradoxical right upper quadrant pain despite left-sided biliary anatomy, which may delay diagnosis.Careful interpretation of unexpected findings, such as dextrocardia, is essential for early recognition of laterality disorders.Laparoscopic cholecystectomy in SIT can be safely performed using a mirror-image operating room setup and trocar placement.Successful surgery depends primarily on adherence to the critical view of safety rather than on modification of standard operative principles.Paradoxical symptom localization and ergonomic challenges represent key diagnostic and technical pitfalls in SIT.

SIT is a rare congenital laterality disorder with an estimated incidence ranging from 1 in 8000 to 1 in 25 000 live births[1,2]. Although the condition itself is usually asymptomatic, it presents significant diagnostic and technical challenges when common surgical diseases occur. Cholelithiasis is not more prevalent in patients with SIT than in the general population; nevertheless, diagnosis may be delayed because abdominal pain does not always correspond to the anatomical position of the affected organ[1,3].

One of the most intriguing manifestations of biliary disease in SIT is paradoxical pain localization. While inflammation of a left-sided gallbladder would be expected to produce left upper quadrant (LUQ) or epigastric pain, several published reports have described patients presenting with conventional right upper quadrant (RUQ) pain despite complete visceral transposition[1,4,5]. The exact neurophysiological basis of this phenomenon remains uncertain.

Proposed mechanisms include incomplete reversal of cortical functional lateralization, preserved organization of visceral afferent pathways, and complex central processing of visceral nociceptive signals during embryological development[4,6].

From a surgical perspective, laparoscopic cholecystectomy in SIT requires considerably more than simple mirror-image trocar placement. Surgeons must continuously adapt their visuospatial orientation, hand dominance, and instrument coordination while preserving the universal principles of safe biliary surgery, particularly achievement of the critical view of safety before division of any structures[3,7–10]. Consequently, meticulous preoperative planning and ergonomic adaptation are essential for minimizing technical difficulty and avoiding biliary injury.

Although more than 100 laparoscopic cholecystectomies in patients with SIT have been reported, most publications focus primarily on the rarity of the anatomical anomaly rather than on its diagnostic implications or operative ergonomics[1]. Furthermore, paradoxical RUQ pain remains an uncommon presentation that continues to pose a diagnostic challenge for emergency physicians and surgeons alike[1,4].

We report a patient with SIT who presented with classic RUQ pain despite having a left-sided gallbladder and underwent successful laparoscopic cholecystectomy using a mirror-image operative approach. In addition to describing the operative strategy, this report discusses the neuroanatomical basis for paradoxical pain localization, practical ergonomic modifications during minimally invasive surgery, and lessons derived from contemporary literature that may facilitate the management of similar patients. This case report adheres to the SCARE 2025 Criteria[11].

Case presentation

A 48-year-old Persian woman presented to the emergency department with a 2-day history of progressively worsening RUQ abdominal pain. The pain was dull, constant, and non-radiating, with no clear relationship to food intake. She denied fever, nausea, vomiting, jaundice, changes in bowel habits, or urinary symptoms.

Her medical history was unremarkable, with no previous abdominal surgery, chronic medical illnesses, or regular medication use. There was no relevant family history of congenital anomalies, laterality disorders, or hepatobiliary disease.

On admission, the patient was afebrile and hemodynamically stable. Physical examination demonstrated localized tenderness in the RUQ without guarding, rebound tenderness, or signs of generalized peritonitis. Murphy’s sign was considered equivocal because of the unexpected localization of pain.

The remainder of the physical examination was unremarkable.

Laboratory investigations revealed no significant leukocytosis or biochemical evidence of biliary obstruction. Liver function tests were within normal limits except for a mildly elevated alkaline phosphatase level (245 U/L). The white blood cell count was 4.0 × 103/μL with 37.7% neutrophils, and C-reactive protein measured 3.2 mg/L.

Cardiac biomarkers were within normal limits.

Routine electrocardiography (ECG) unexpectedly revealed dextrocardia, prompting further evaluation for a possible laterality disorder. Chest radiography confirmed a right-sided cardiac apex and a right-sided gastric bubble, strongly suggesting SIT (Fig. 1).

(As this was the only original preoperative radiograph available, Figure 1 is presented to document the available imaging findings and should not be interpreted as demonstrating clinically significant colonic distension or as being directly related to the primary diagnosis.) Figure 1.Initial radiographic findings suggestive of situs inversus totalis. (A) Supine abdominal radiograph showing a right-sided gastric bubble. (B) Upright abdominal radiograph confirming the right-sided gastric bubble without pneumoperitoneum.

(C) Chest radiograph demonstrating dextrocardia and mirror-image thoracoabdominal anatomy consistent with situs inversus totalis. (This was the only original radiograph available and is presented to document the available imaging findings; the apparent colonic distension should not be interpreted as clinically significant or directly related to the primary diagnosis.)

Subsequent abdominal ultrasonography (US) demonstrated multiple gallstones within a left-sided gallbladder, associated with mild wall thickening but without biliary duct dilatation. Contrast-enhanced computed tomography (CT) confirmed complete SIT, demonstrating a left-sided liver and gallbladder with the stomach and spleen located in the RUQ (Fig. 2).

Figure 2 is intended to demonstrate the visceral laterality associated with SIT rather than the gallstones, which were identified on US. Figure 2.Contrast-enhanced abdominal CT confirming situs inversus totalis. (A) Coronal CT image demonstrating a left-sided liver and gallbladder with a right-sided stomach and spleen.

(B) Axial CT image confirming mirror-image transposition of the abdominal viscera, consistent with situs inversus totalis. (The gallstones identified on ultrasonography were not clearly visualized on CT.)

Because congenital cardiovascular anomalies may coexist with SIT, a comprehensive preoperative assessment was performed before surgery[1]. Transthoracic echocardiography demonstrated structurally normal cardiac anatomy, apart from dextrocardia, with preserved ventricular function. Following multidisciplinary evaluation by the cardiology and anesthesiology teams, the patient was considered an appropriate candidate for laparoscopic cholecystectomy.

For perioperative antibiotic prophylaxis, ceftriaxone (1 g) and metronidazole (500 mg) were administered intravenously as single doses before the skin incision.

The operating room was arranged in a complete mirror-image configuration (Fig. 3). The primary surgeon and camera assistant stood on the patient’s right side, whereas the first assistant stood on the left.

Pneumoperitoneum was established using an open Hasson technique through a 10-mm infraumbilical trocar. Three additional trocars were inserted in a mirror-image fashion replicating the conventional laparoscopic cholecystectomy setup described for patients with normal anatomy[3,7]. Figure 3.Intraoperative findings during mirror-image laparoscopic cholecystectomy in situs inversus totalis.

(A) External view demonstrating the mirror-image laparoscopic port placement and operative configuration. (B) Laparoscopic view showing the left-sided gallbladder with identification and dissection of the cystic duct and cystic artery before clipping and division. (C) Schematic illustration of the operating-room configuration, showing the mirror-image arrangement of the surgeon, assistant, camera operator, monitor, and laparoscopic trocar positions.

Initial laparoscopic exploration confirmed complete mirror-image transposition of the abdominal viscera. The liver and gallbladder were located in the LUQ, whereas the stomach and spleen occupied the RUQ. Dense inflammatory adhesions surrounding the gallbladder were carefully dissected using a combination of blunt dissection and electrocautery.

After meticulous exposure of Calot’s triangle, the cystic duct and cystic artery were clearly identified, and the critical view of safety was achieved before clipping and division of either structure, in accordance with established principles of safe cholecystectomy. The cystic duct and cystic artery were secured with laparoscopic clips before division. A drain was not placed at the end of the procedure (Fig.

3).

The principal technical challenge arose from the reversed anatomical orientation rather than from any anatomical variation of the biliary tree. Continuous visuospatial adaptation was required throughout the dissection because the mirror-image anatomy altered instrument trajectories and surgeon ergonomics. For a right-handed surgeon, fine dissection frequently had to be performed using the nondominant hand while maintaining adequate countertraction with the dominant hand.

Despite these ergonomic constraints, the procedure was completed entirely laparoscopically without intraoperative complications, bile duct injury, excessive bleeding, or conversion to open surgery[7,8].

The gallbladder was retrieved in a specimen bag through the epigastric port. A final laparoscopic inspection confirmed meticulous hemostasis and the absence of bile leakage. The patient recovered uneventfully, resumed oral intake on the first postoperative day, and was discharged home in good general condition.

Histopathological examination confirmed chronic calculous cholecystitis without dysplasia or malignancy. At 6-month follow-up, the patient remained asymptomatic, with complete resolution of abdominal pain and no evidence of postoperative complications or recurrent biliary disease. A summary of the patient’s clinical course, including presentation, diagnostic evaluation, surgical management, and follow-up, is provided in Table 1.Table 1Timeline of the patient’s clinical course.Time pointClinical eventsDay −2The patient presented with a 2-day history of worsening right upper quadrant abdominal pain and localized tenderness.Day 0 – initial evaluationDextrocardia was unexpectedly identified on electrocardiography.

Abdominal ultrasonography demonstrated a left-sided gallbladder containing multiple gallstones.Day 0 – further evaluationContrast-enhanced CT of the abdomen confirmed situs inversus totalis with complete visceral laterality.Day 0 – surgical managementFollowing preoperative cardiology and anesthesia assessment, mirror-image laparoscopic cholecystectomy was performed. The critical view of safety was obtained, and the gallbladder was removed without intraoperative complications.Postoperative day 1The patient had an uneventful postoperative recovery and was discharged according to routine postoperative care.6-month follow-upThe patient remained asymptomatic with no reported postoperative complications.

Discussion

SIT is a rare congenital laterality disorder characterized by complete mirror-image transposition of the thoracic and abdominal viscera[1]. Although the condition itself is usually asymptomatic, it substantially complicates the diagnosis and surgical management of otherwise common abdominal diseases. Cholelithiasis occurs with a frequency comparable to that of the general population; however, once biliary disease develops, clinicians are confronted with two major challenges: atypical symptom localization and unfamiliar operative orientation[1,3].

The distinctive contribution of this report lies in the combination of paradoxical pain localization, incidental recognition of the laterality disorder via dextrocardia, and detailed documentation of the ergonomic adaptations required during laparoscopic surgery. First, despite complete transposition of the abdominal organs, the patient presented with classic RUQ pain rather than the expected left-sided symptoms. Second, laparoscopic cholecystectomy was successfully completed using a mirror-image operative configuration without compromising the principles of safe biliary dissection.

Together, these observations demonstrate that the principal challenge in SIT is not the abnormal anatomy itself but the cognitive assumptions derived from normal anatomical orientation.

One of the most intriguing aspects of this case is the paradoxical localization of pain. Classical anatomical teaching predicts that inflammation of a left-sided gallbladder should produce LUQ or epigastric pain. Nevertheless, several reports have documented patients with SIT presenting with conventional RUQ pain despite complete visceral transposition[1,4,5].

Although uncommon, this phenomenon has considerable clinical importance because clinicians may prematurely exclude biliary pathology when symptom localization appears inconsistent with organ position.

The neurophysiological basis of paradoxical pain localization remains incompletely understood. One proposed mechanism is incomplete reversal of cortical functional lateralization during embryological development. Although the abdominal viscera undergo complete mirror-image transposition, cortical networks involved in visceral nociceptive processing may retain their usual functional organization, resulting in preservation of conventional pain perception[4].

Another plausible explanation involves the complex organization of visceral afferent pathways. Unlike somatic sensory innervation, visceral afferent fibers follow intricate autonomic and spinal pathways that may not undergo complete mirror-image rearrangement in patients with SIT[6]. While these hypotheses remain speculative, they provide biologically plausible explanations for the discordance observed in our patient and in previously published reports.

From a diagnostic standpoint, this case illustrates the importance of avoiding anchoring bias when evaluating abdominal pain. Reliance solely on the anatomical location of pain may delay diagnosis in patients with laterality disorders. In the present case, the unexpected finding of dextrocardia during routine ECG prompted further imaging, ultimately leading to the diagnosis of SIT before surgery.

This observation emphasizes that unexpected findings such as dextrocardia or a right-sided gastric bubble on plain radiography should immediately prompt reassessment of visceral orientation rather than the exclusion of biliary disease[1,3].

Preoperative imaging plays a pivotal role for these patients. US remains the preferred first-line investigation for suspected gallstone disease, whereas contrast-enhanced CT provides a comprehensive assessment of visceral orientation and facilitates operative planning[3,7]. Additional imaging modalities, such as magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography, may be useful when biliary anatomical variations or choledocholithiasis are suspected[7].

The technical challenge of laparoscopic cholecystectomy in SIT extends well beyond mirror-image trocar placement. Reversed anatomy fundamentally alters visuospatial orientation, hand dominance, instrument trajectory, and surgeon ergonomics. Right-handed surgeons often experience greater technical difficulty because precise dissection within Calot’s triangle must be performed under unfamiliar ergonomic conditions[3,7,8].

Consequently, successful surgery depends less on modification of the operative technique than on deliberate ergonomic adaptation while maintaining the universal principles of safe biliary surgery.

Emerging artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted navigation technologies may provide additional support during laparoscopic procedures involving complex or reversed anatomy. AI-based systems have recently been investigated for anatomical recognition and intraoperative identification of critical structures during laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Although AI-assisted technology was not used in the present case, such systems may have potential value in supporting spatial orientation and anatomical recognition in patients with SIT.

Further clinical evaluation is required to determine their feasibility and effectiveness in this setting[9].

In the present case, a complete mirror-image operating room arrangement allowed comfortable instrument handling without altering the essential steps of laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Careful adhesiolysis, meticulous identification of the cystic duct and cystic artery, and strict achievement of the critical view of safety enabled the safe completion of the procedure without bile duct injury or conversion to open surgery. Our experience is consistent with the systematic review by Enciu et al, which demonstrated that favorable outcomes are primarily related to careful operative planning and adherence to standard surgical principles rather than any specific trocar configuration[1].

To further contextualize the present case, we reviewed published cases of laparoscopic cholecystectomy in patients with SIT. Table 2 provides a concise comparison of the present patient with representative published cases, focusing on pain localization, diagnostic evaluation, and operative considerations. The complete list of reviewed cases is provided in Supplemental Digital Content Table S1, available at: https://links.lww.com/IJSCR/A200.Table 2Comparison of the present case with representative published cases.CasePresentation/pain localizationDiagnostic findingsOperative approach/technical featuresOutcomePresent caseRight upper quadrant pain for 2 days; localized tenderness; Murphy’s sign equivocalDextrocardia on ECG; CXR and CT confirmed SIT; US demonstrated multiple gallstones in left-sided gallbladderMirror-image OR configuration; reversed trocar placement; right-handed surgeon; meticulous adhesiolysis; critical view of safety achieved before clipping/divisionUneventful recovery; discharged in good condition; asymptomatic at 6-month follow-upLloyd-davies et al, 2005Epigastric pain radiating to the back; no definite RUQ/LUQ tendernessDextrocardia on ECG/CXR; US showed stones in left-sided gallbladder; CT confirmed SITMirror-image theatre setup; ports placed on the left; assistant retracted Hartmann’s pouch to facilitate right-handed dissection of Calot’s triangleUneventful recovery; discharged the following dayAli et al, 2013[2]Vague upper abdominal/epigastric pain radiating to the back; epigastric and LUQ tendernessPrevious dextrocardia known; ECG/echocardiography confirmed; US showed multiple stones in left-sided gallbladder; CT confirmed SITMirror-image port placement; laparoscopic cholecystectomy performed with adaptation for right-handed surgeonUneventful postoperative courseMckay and blake, 2005[12]Acute cholecystitis with atypical pain localization reported in the SIT literatureSIT recognized by cardiac/abdominal imaging; gallbladder located on leftMirror-image laparoscopic approach with ergonomic adaptationSuccessful laparoscopic cholecystectomyHall et al, 2010[13]Left upper quadrant pain in a patient with known SITKnown SIT; gallstones diagnosed preoperativelyMirror-image laparoscopic approach; surgeon adapted instrument orientation to reversed anatomyNo postoperative complications; discharged after surgeryCampos and sipes et al, 1991[14]Symptomatic gallstone diseaseSIT recognized in the preoperative assessmentFirst reported laparoscopic cholecystectomy in SIT; mirror-image laparoscopic approachSuccessful laparoscopic cholecystectomySIT, situs inversus totalis; US, ultrasonography; CT, computed tomography; ECG, electrocardiography; CXR, chest radiography; RUQ, right upper quadrant; LUQ, left upper quadrant.

The available literature demonstrates that laparoscopic cholecystectomy can be performed safely across a broad spectrum of biliary diseases, including chronic cholecystitis, acute cholecystitis, choledocholithiasis, and biliary pancreatitis. However, paradoxical right upper quadrant pain has been described only in a minority of reports, underscoring the unusual clinical presentation observed in our patient. Likewise, no single trocar configuration or operating room layout has demonstrated clear superiority, suggesting that surgeon familiarity and ergonomic adaptation are more important than adherence to a predefined technical approach.

The principal strength of this report lies in the coexistence of paradoxical RUQ pain and detailed documentation of ergonomic adaptation during laparoscopic cholecystectomy. In contrast to many previously published case reports that primarily emphasize the rarity of SIT, our report focuses on the diagnostic reasoning, cognitive challenges, and practical surgical considerations that directly influence clinical decision-making. Furthermore, the accompanying review of previously published cases provides additional context for understanding the uniqueness of the present case.

Several limitations should be acknowledged. As a single case report, our findings cannot establish the true prevalence of paradoxical pain localization or determine the optimal operative strategy for all patients with SIT. Furthermore, no neurophysiological investigations were performed to validate the proposed mechanisms of pain perception.

Nevertheless, the consistency of our observations with previously published reports supports the clinical relevance of paradoxical symptom localization and reinforces the importance of individualized operative planning.

Conclusion

SIT may present with paradoxical RUQ pain despite a left-sided gallbladder, potentially creating a diagnostic pitfall. Careful preoperative imaging is essential to establish visceral orientation and facilitate operative planning. During laparoscopic cholecystectomy, deliberate ergonomic adaptation to the mirror-image anatomy, combined with strict adherence to the critical view of safety, allows safe completion of the procedure.

Awareness of these principles may facilitate timely diagnosis and confident surgical management in patients with this rare anatomical variant.

Related articles

PubMed

Conditioned pain modulation is associated with anesthesia efficacy in patients with temporomandibular disorder.

Abstract Conditioned pain modulation (CPM) assesses descending pain inhibition in humans and has been shown to be clinically relevant. However, the possible contribution of the CPM response to the efficacy of local anesthetics remains poorly understood. This study aimed to evaluate the association between the CPM response and the efficacy of topical anesthesia applied to the trigeminal region in females with chronic orofacial pain and healthy participants. Thirty-five females with painful tempo...

PubMed

Postoperative fluid collection at the proximal neurovascular bundle level is associated with early pain and reduced knee extensor strength after direct anterior total hip arthroplasty.

Background Early anterolateral thigh pain after direct anterior total hip arthroplasty (DAA-THA) is common, and more severe symptoms than expected in the usual postoperative course can be difficult to interpret clinically. This study evaluated whether a landmark-based ultrasonographic pattern of postoperative fluid collection (POFC) at a reference level corresponding to a reported course of the proximal neurovascular bundle is associated with early pain and knee extensor strength. Methods In...