Vacuum Drying Maintains the Integrity of DNA and Protects the Stability of PCR Amplification under Accelerated Aging.

Save

DNA, with its advantages such as ultrahigh storage density, low energy consumption, and ultralong potential lifespan, has become a new generation of storage medium with great development potential. The stability of DNA storage directly determines the reliability of information retrieval. Conventional cryopreservation not only incurs high costs but also leads to DNA degradation over long-term storage.

Although current DNA protection methods can delay degradation to some extent, they can hinder DNA release and interfere with downstream PCR amplification and sequencing processes. In this study, solid DNA samples were prepared using vacuum drying without exogenous additives, and accelerated aging experiments were conducted at 70 °C to investigate the integrity of DNA and the stability of PCR amplification. We found that vacuum-dried DNA maintained excellent integrity after being heated for 40 h.

DNA heated for 0–30 h showed no significant difference in cycle threshold (Ct) values compared with the unheated control, even after 1000-fold dilution. A significant increase in the Ct value was observed only under critical conditions, in which the DNA sample was heated for 40 h and diluted 1000 times. Under different drying temperatures, the effects of 50 °C vacuum drying and lyophilization on protecting DNA stability are comparable.

Our research provides important insights into the storage of long templates and the preservation of nucleic acid samples in fields such as medicine and forensic science.

Introduction

Data storage media have undergone multiple technological iterations, including paper, film, and hard disk, with significant improvements in storage performance. However, there is a widespread issue of significantly shortened storage lifespan, making it difficult to meet the developmental needs of long-term archiving and permanent storage of massive amounts of cold data.− DNA, with its advantages such as ultrahigh storage density, low energy consumption, and ultralong potential lifespan, has become a new generation of storage medium with great development potential.− In the process of DNA data storage, the stability of DNA storage directly determines the duration of information preservation and data fidelity and is one of the core bottlenecks restricting the application of this technology. Currently, conventional DNA preservation methods in laboratories primarily rely on freezing at −20 °C.

However, long-term frozen storage can still induce DNA fragmentation and depurination., At the same time, large-scale cryogenic refrigeration equipment and continuous energy consumption incur high costs, making it difficult to meet the industrial demands for large-scale, low-cost, and long-term archiving of DNA storage.

Hydrolysis and oxidation are considered the primary pathways leading to DNA degradation., Most DNA preservation methods primarily focus on isolating DNA from moisture and oxygen. Currently, approaches to enhance the stability of DNA storage include simple drying on Whatman filter paper,, poly­(vinyl alcohol) plates, trehalose, calcium chloride (magnesium chloride),, hydroxyapatite, exogenous nucleic acid carriers, and encapsulation in silica nanoparticles.− Although these approaches can delay the degradation rate of DNA to some extent and enhance the stability of DNA storage, they generally have significant drawbacks. Processes such as nanoencapsulation involve cumbersome operational steps, which are not conducive to the rapid preparation and application of large quantities of DNA storage samples.

The addition of protective additives can form a dense barrier layer on the surface of DNA molecules, making it difficult to elute DNA. During the redissolution process, strong corrosive solutions are often required, which can inhibit the release efficiency of template DNA and directly interfere with downstream information reading processes, such as PCR amplification and high-throughput sequencing, resulting in weakened amplification signals and increased data reading error rates. Therefore, developing a DNA storage approach that does not require additional protective agents, is easy to operate, and balances storage stability with downstream amplification activity is a crucial issue that urgently needs to be addressed to improve DNA stability.

Vacuum drying, which can achieve dehydration and deoxygenation of DNA, is a simple and convenient method to enhance the stability of DNA storage without the need to add exogenous protective media. Currently, research regarding additive-free vacuum-dried DNA integrity and its PCR amplification stability evaluated by a systematic PCR dilution readout remains limited. Here, this study employed the bacteriophage lambda DNA (λDNA) as a model for long DNA templates to investigate the storage stability of vacuum-dried DNA using accelerated aging experiments.

We found that the integrity of DNA can be maintained within 40 h, and DNA samples heated for 0–30 h retained stable PCR amplification performance after 1000-fold dilution. This indicates that DNA under vacuum drying conditions maintains integrity and stable PCR amplification activity. This study provides important insights into the storage of long templates and the preservation of nucleic acid samples in fields such as medicine and forensic science.

Results

DNA Samples Dried at 50 °C Maintained the Integrity of DNA

To investigate the stability of DNA storage, we employed the accelerated aging experiment as a model. The agarose gel electrophoresis can detect the integrity of DNA and visually reflect the degradation of DNA. First, we investigated the effect of accelerated aging experiments on the integrity of DNA in solution using agarose gel electrophoresis.

As the heating time increased, the single main band gradually degraded into shorter fragments or even completely disappeared, indicating significant damage to DNA integrity (Figure a). Then, DNA samples were vacuum-dried at 50 °C to investigate the effect of accelerated aging experiments on the integrity of DNA. The vacuum-dried DNA samples were still clearly visible and their length remained unchanged, indicating that heating for 40 h after drying did not cause DNA to break into smaller fragments (Figure b).

The relative intensity of high-molecular weight (HMW) bands was quantified from gel images. Accelerated aging led to the complete disappearance of HMW band intensity in DNA solution, while vacuum-dried DNA maintained high HMW band intensity over the same heating period (Figure S1), that is, vacuum drying has a significant protective effect on the integrity of DNA under accelerated aging conditions.

DNA Samples Dried at 50 °C Protected the Stability of PCR Amplification under High-Dilution Conditions

DNA degradation may reduce the effective template amount in PCR reactions, potentially leading to an increase in the Ct values. Further, we investigated the impact of accelerated aging on the PCR amplification performance. First, the amplification performance of the original DNA samples after accelerated aging was investigated.

With the increase of heating time, the amplification curves of different samples almost overlap without significant difference (Figure a), and there is also no significant difference in melting curves (Figure b). Compared to the control group that was not heated after drying, heating for 5–40 h after drying resulted in a slightly increasing trend in Ct values (Figure c), indicating a slight decrease in the effective template amount. The position and intensity of PCR products in agarose gel electrophoresis were not obviously affected (Figure d), indicating that heating DNA for 0–40 h after vacuum drying did not have an obvious impact on the yield of PCR products.

In addition, by sequencing the PCR products, the alignment accuracy reached more than 99% (Table S1), indicating that vacuum drying not only protects DNA integrity but also does not interfere with downstream PCR amplification and sequencing processes.

High template concentrations yield low Ct values, which may mask the differences between samples. Therefore, we diluted the heated DNA at different ratios and performed PCR amplification to investigate the stability of PCR amplification. Similar phenomena were observed when DNA was diluted 10–100 times, and heating for 40 h did not have a significant effect on Ct values (Figures S2–S3).

Until the sample was diluted 1000 times and heated for 40 h, the amplification curve significantly deviated from the other groups and the end point fluorescence also decreased significantly (Figure a). Additionally, the Ct value increased significantly, indicating that the effective template amount in the DNA samples after heating for 40 h was significantly reduced (Figure c). Melting curves combined with agarose gel electrophoresis showed that PCR products were target products (Figure b,d).

After further dilution to 10,000 times, no target product was observed, indicating that this is already a critical amplification condition (Figure S4).

Lyophilization Preserved the Integrity of DNA and the Stability of PCR Amplification

Due to the previous dehydration method being vacuum drying at 50 °C, there may be heat stress during this process. However, lyophilization, which completes the dehydration process at a low temperature of −50 °C, has the potential to avoid the impact of heat stress on the DNA integrity. Therefore, we also investigated the impact of accelerated aging under lyophilization on DNA integrity and PCR amplification stability.

For DNA samples dried at different temperatures, no obvious difference in band positions was observed (Figure a), and there was no significant difference in the intensity of HMW bands (Figure S5). ΔCt represents the difference in Ct between experimental groups and the control group, and there is no significant difference in the ΔCt values of PCR amplification when dried at different temperatures (Figures b, S6). These results showed that different drying temperatures yield comparable DNA integrity and PCR amplification activity under accelerated aging conditions.

Discussion

Our research demonstrates that there are significant differences in thermal degradation behavior between aqueous DNA and vacuum-dried solid DNA under accelerated aging conditions at 70 °C. With increasing heat treatment time, aqueous DNA fragments gradually decrease and degrade into short fragments of approximately 250 bp or less. Continuing to extend the heat treatment time ultimately leads to the disappearance of short fragments.

However, the vacuum-dried solid DNA still maintains long-chain integrity and stable PCR amplification activity under 1000-fold dilution within 30 h of accelerated aging. This difference indicates that water and oxygen may be the main factors in the degradation of DNA fragments under heat stress. We note that the λDNA solution was supplied in 10 mM Tris–HCl containing 1 mM EDTA.

Even after 10-fold dilution, small amounts of residual salts remained in the dried solid. The term “additive-free” here indicates no additional exogenous additives. The residual salt may affect the stability of DNA, but their concentration is the same among the groups.

Therefore, the observed protective effect is mainly due to vacuum drying.

In aqueous solutions and oxygen-containing environments, the increase in temperature accelerates these degradation pathways: oxidative degradation, hydrolytic cytosine deamination, and depurination.,, Eventually, long DNA molecules are broken into random small fragments, and the continuous template regions required for PCR amplification are disrupted. In contrast, vacuum drying can remove a large amount of water and oxygen, which greatly inhibits chain breakage reactions in solid DNA; therefore, long DNA chains remain intact after accelerated aging treatment. After rehydration, vacuum-dried DNA can restore its natural conformation and serve as an effective template for PCR amplification.

It should be noted that inadequate sealing of plastic containers can still cause slow DNA damage due to trace amounts of water or oxygen residue. Therefore, complete drying and exclusion of oxygen are crucial for maximizing the DNA storage stability.

The similar performance of different drying temperatures can be rationalized by the time-dependent thermal degradation of DNA. Thermal damage depends on both the temperature and exposure duration. Although vacuum drying at 50 °C is performed at a higher temperature than lyophilization, the drying duration is short.

As a result, the total accumulated thermal degradation of DNA during drying remains low. Lyophilization at −50 °C avoids heat stress entirely, yet this theoretical benefit did not produce measurable improvements in DNA integrity or PCR amplification activity after accelerated aging under our experimental conditions.

Several limitations of the present study should be acknowledged. All experiments were performed using a single λDNA model under controlled laboratory conditions. DNA data storage typically employs short-chain DNA, which has different degradation kinetics compared to long-chain genome DNA.

Real-sample preservation scenarios with complex biological matrices, diverse DNA fragment sizes, and fluctuating humidity were not investigated here. In addition, due to time constraints, DNA storage at room temperature was not performed in this study. It should be noted that the room temperature storage conditions of real samples cannot be completely reproduced by accelerated aging conditions, and the actual room-temperature storage life cannot be quantitatively extrapolated from accelerated aging experiments.

Conclusions

In conclusion, we have confirmed that the additive-free solid-state drying system can maintain the storage stability of DNA. Vacuum drying can preserve DNA integrity, always maintaining a single band. High-dilution PCR amplification experiments showed that solid DNA samples heated for 0–30 h maintained the same amplification activity as the control group when diluted 1000 times.

It was only under the critical amplification conditions of a 1000-fold dilution of DNA samples heated for 40 h that an increase of about 4.45 ± 0.37 cycles in the Ct value was observed. Different drying temperatures had no significant effect on DNA storage stability. This work systematically evaluated DNA stability under accelerated aging conditions after vacuum drying, providing important references for molecular diagnostics in fields such as medicine and forensic science, especially for the storage of long templates.

Despite these promising observations, the practical application of vacuum-dried DNA storage still faces several key challenges, including different sizes of DNA fragments and long-term room-temperature storage.

Materials and Methods

Materials

λDNA and Ex Taq DNA polymerase (RR001A) were purchased from TaKaRa (Dalian, China). The fluorescent label reagent (GelRed), DNA markers (BM15000, BM2000+, BM2000), and 6× loading buffer were purchased from Biomed (Beijing, China). All primers were synthesized by Sangon Biotech (Shanghai, China).

SYBR Green I was purchased from Biosharp (Shanghai, China). Agarose was purchased from Tsingke Biotech (Beijing, China).

Preparation of Dried DNA Samples

The commercially purchased λDNA (350–400 ng/μL) was stored in 10 mM Tris–HCl (pH 8.0) with 1 mM EDTA. The DNA solution was diluted with nuclease-free water, and the DNA concentration was measured using the NanoDrop (BIO-GENER). A series of λDNA solutions (35 ng/μL) with a volume of 50 μL were prepared in 200 μL PCR tubes and were placed in a 50 °C vacuum drying oven (Yiheng) and a lyophilizer instrument (Sheyan).

The vacuum pressure was maintained at 100 mbar for the 50 °C vacuum drying oven and 0.5 mbar for the lyophilizer. For vacuum drying at 50 °C, DNA samples were dried for 1 h until constant weight. For the lyophilizer, DNA samples were completely frozen and then dried in the vacuum device for 4–6 h until reaching constant weight.

After complete drying, the total mass of the tube plus dried solids returned to the original mass of empty tubes. Constant weight was defined as two consecutive mass measurements differing by ≤ 0.001 g. Gravimetric analysis was only used to confirm complete removal of the aqueous solvent.

After drying, tubes were sealed by simple capping, with no inert gas backfilling.

Accelerated Aging Experiments

The initial condition of all DNA samples before accelerated aging was the same. The dry DNA samples were stored in a −20 °C refrigerator for the control group, while the heated samples were placed in an electric hot air drying oven for accelerated aging at 70 °C. After heating for a certain period of time, the samples were taken out and stored at −20 °C and then uniformly dissolved with nuclease-free water for subsequent experiments.

DNA Integrity Detection

After fully dissolving the dried λDNA with the same volume of nuclease-free water, 5 μL of λDNA was taken for agarose gel electrophoresis detection. λDNA was loaded into the 0.8% agarose gel stained with the ultrasensitive fluorescent nucleic acid chromophore (GelRed) and electrophoresed at 110 V for 40 min. Results of gel electrophoresis were observed with a gel imager (Biolight).

PCR Amplification

DNA in solution degrades into fragments of approximately 250 bp or less, and short amplicons can still amplify these short degradation products and thus fail to sensitively detect loss of long-template continuity. Therefore, the long amplicon (922 bp) was employed to investigate the integrity of long templates. The quantitative PCR (qPCR) system was constructed as follows.

The 50 μL qPCR system includes λDNA, primers (0.2 μM each), 1.25 U DNA polymerase, 5 μL of 10× PCR buffer, dNTP mixture (0.4 mM each), and 1 μL of SYBR Green I, and the remaining volume was filled with nuclease-free water. The DNA templates were samples heated for different durations, which were then diluted 0–10,000 times and used as templates in PCR amplification. The target sequence of 922 bp was expected to be amplified, and the sequences of λDNA primers are 5′-CGAACTTCAAAAAGCATCGGGA-3′ (forward primer) and 5′-ATATCTGGGCTTCACTGCCG-3′ (reverse primer).

The nuclease-free water was used to dissolve and dilute the primers. The qPCR procedure is as follows: the predenaturation process at 95 °C lasted for 30 s, followed by 40 cycles, each including a denaturation process at 95 °C for 6 s, an annealing process at 58 °C for 15 s, and an extension process at 72 °C for 30 s. The program for the melting curve is as follows: from 60 to 95 °C, rising by 1 °C at each step with the continuous recording of fluorescence.

The entire qPCR program was performed on a real-time fluorescence qPCR instrument (BIO-GENER). PCR products were loaded into the 2% agarose gel stained with the GelRed nucleic acid chromophore and electrophoresed at 110 V for 30 min. Gel electrophoresis images were acquired using a gel imager (Biolight).

The qPCR standard curve for the 922 bp amplicon gave a slope of −3.22 (Figure S7), corresponding to an amplification efficiency of 104%. The amplicon identity was verified by agarose gel electrophoresis and Sanger sequencing.

Sequencing and Sequence Analysis

PCR products were sequenced by Sangon Biotech (Shanghai, China). For sequence analysis, the first 20 nucleotides of the raw sequencing were trimmed to remove low-quality signals originating from the initial stage of the Sanger sequencing. The trimmed sequences were locally aligned with the reference amplicon using the WATER program from EMBOSS software.

The identity value from the alignment was adopted as a measure of the accuracy of PCR amplification.

Data Analysis

All data were obtained from three independent biological replicates. Each biological replicate contained three qPCR technical replicates, and the averaged Ct value of technical replicates was used for subsequent statistical analysis. Densitometric analysis of gel images was performed using ImageJ software.

The intensity of the HMW band was quantified, and relative intensities were normalized to the control group. Origin software was employed for graphical presentation, and GraphPad Prism was applied for significance analysis. For comparing the effect of heating times on Ct values and band intensity, one-way ANOVA combined with Dunnett’s multiple comparison test was performed to compare experimental groups with the control group.

When comparing the effects of different drying temperatures on Ct values and band intensity at identical heating times, two-way ANOVA combined with Sidak’s multiple comparisons test was applied for statistical analysis. P < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

Supplementary Material

Related articles

PubMed

Laboratory-based assessment of quantitative PCR to describe Arctic fish assemblages in surface water affected by acid rock drainage.

Permafrost thaw has been identified as a cause of metal mobilization from acid rock drainage and transport to Arctic rivers. Elevated metal concentrations and precipitation of Fe(III) minerals (i.e., rusting) in surface waters deteriorates water quality and raises questions about ecosystem effects, especially to the health of fish species. Environmental DNA (eDNA) analyses could be used for assessing impacts of acid rock drainage to fish assemblages but may be prone to biases like polymerase cha...

PLOS

Laboratory-based assessment of quantitative PCR to describe Arctic fish assemblages in surface water affected by acid rock drainage

Permafrost thaw has been identified as a cause of metal mobilization from acid rock drainage and transport to Arctic rivers. Elevated metal concentrations and precipitation of Fe(III) minerals (i.e., rusting) in surface waters deteriorates water quality and raises questions about ecosystem effects, especially to the health of fish species. Environmental DNA (eDNA) analyses could be used for assessing impacts of acid rock drainage to fish assemblages but may be prone to biases like polymerase cha...